Edinburgh Guide  
Theatre in Edinburgh -- Scotland
Edinburgh : A&E : Theatre: Reviews
 

Theatre listings >
Theatre Index >>

1984 Adapted from George Orwell's novel - Tour

Adapter - Alan Lyddiard
Director - Alan Lyddiard and Mark Murphy
Designer - Neil Murray
Music - John Alder
Film - Mark Murphy
Lighting - Jon Linstrum
Company - Northern Stage Ensemble in co-production with the Derby Playhouse
Venues & Dates - Tour details at end of review
Seen - Dundee Rep
Reviewer - Rachel Natanson

Loud, brash and, quite rightly, frightening

This adaptation is from its outset loud, brash and, quite rightly, frightening. It places its scene well with film footage of wintry Moscow projected on to the big blank screens that make up part of the play's industrial, bleak looking set. With minimal props it transforms, by swift but sometimes distracting scene changes, into the many settings require.

1984 is hard to bring to the stage and to a live audience, due to its subject and being a well-known tale. Lyddiard's and Murphy's 1984 relies overly on its filmed images of violence which, in today's media - saturated with violent scenes - is not as effective as the far simpler image of Winston, Craig Conway, lying crying with pain at O'Brien's, Mark Calvert, feet. The cast do do well and include Jill Halfpenny as Julia with a girlish-ness and unapologetic nature. Conway's portrayal of Winston's human pain and suffering, and Mark Calvert's O'Brien whose smiles exist only in O'Brien's head and the audience's mind.

The play doesn't quite stand on its own as it relies on knowledge of the story - a person unfamiliar with it could be lost and confused by the world portrayed. At the start, the film footage and the set movement is clever but as it carries on it becomes more and more distracting - detracting from the acting going on. Indeed I found myself looking at the images on the screen in preference to the action on the stage. This 1984 is worth a look, and many of the audience do appreciate it but it's not my idea of Orwell's classic.
© Rachel Natanson 26 February 2002

Tour dates
8 & 9 Feb 2002 at 8:30pm Paris, Theatre a Chatillon 00 33 1 46 57 22 11
12 - 16 Feb at 7:30pm Newcastle Playhouse 0191 230 5151
19 - 23 Feb at 7:45pm mat Thurs 2pm Basingstoke Haymarket Theatre 01256 465 566
26 - 2 Mar at 7:45pm mat Sat 2:30pm Dundee Rep 01382 223530
12 - 16 Mar at 7:30pm mat Wed at 2pm Newcastle Playhouse 0191 230 5151
19 - 23 March at 7:30pm mat Thurs 2:30pm Preston Charter Theatre 01772 258858
26 - 30 March 2002 at 7:30pm mat Sat 2:30pm Mold Clwyd Theatr Cymru 01352 755114
End of Tour


Theatre listings >>
Theatre Index >>

E-MAIL THIS PAGE
Enter recipient's e-mail:

 


 


Edinburgh Film
| Theatre | Edinburgh Festival

Edinburgh Accommodation :
Self-catering
| Hotels | Guesthouses | B&Bs | Serviced Apartments | Hostels


EdinburghGuide.com
1998-2007, Edinburgh, Scotland. All rights reserved.