Edinburgh Guide
Edinburgh international festival and fringe
Edinburgh : A&E : Festivals : 2002 : Official Festival
EIF Review

The Girl on The Sofa - World Premiere

Company
Co-production Edinburgh International Festival and the Schaubuhne am Lehniner Platz Berlin
Venue Royal Lyecum Theatre
Address Grindlay St off Lothian Rd
Reviewer Thelma Good

In the programme notes Jon Fosse says, "Theatre is always for you ....... It's about listening." Katherine Mendelsohn, Literary Associate of the Traverse Theatre, also adds in the same programme that the Traverse in commissioning Jon Fosse to write this play in Norwegian and pairing him with David Harrower (Knives in Hens and Kill the Old, Torture The Young) to provide a Scots English dramatic translation, the aim was "recreating the vital signature rhythm and musicality of Jon's language". Listening to this script is what Thomas Ostermeier didn't do. When you read the published script in Scots English the musicality and rhythm do ring out strong and true, but in casting solely English actors, fine though they are, this important element of Harrow's version and Jon's original is completely lost. It's unfortunate that the Traverse could not mount this premiere of the script they originally commissioned, if they had that intention could have remained intact.

Girl On The Sofa
The Girl On The Sofa
Photo © Robbie Jack
Nor is it the only thing in the production which comes between us and the playwright's and translator's intentions. It is a magnificent production with superb lighting by Urs Schonebaum, clear tone singing by Joanna Dudley and music from Matteo Fargion. The set by Rufus Didwiszus is different from the one suggested in the text, no ordinary walls or three paintings but a sloped white stage bounded by upright struts to suggest those walls. The characters can listen and react to the action while they move around beyond the struts in the area before the three sided walls beyond resembling an abandoned, possible industrial building. This device might have worked well but combined with the use of miked-up voices of the actors at times and the loud and abrupt shhh click ending and black out to each section, it was hard to stay focused on the play. These devices continually kept one aware that this was happening in a theatre, where as in truly riveting drama, the theatre walls dissolve and you are there at the edge of the stage snared willingly into the play and its world. The published play has no sections, it flows continuously.

And what is it about? The Woman who paints though no one wants her pictures, her younger self, her older Sister, their often away on the high seas father, their Mother and the Man the Woman is involved with. Also in the play are the Sister Older and the Father Older, the play slips between present and past sometimes interwoven in the same scene, reality echoed by recollection. The Mother is the cause of their Father's final prolonged absence. The play's two time frames are in the Woman's childhood and a present occurring as the Mother, now unseen and unvisited by the Woman but visited by the Sister Older, is dying. It's a painful story of how things in childhood can shape our futures even if we don't want them too.

In taking Fosse's play and directing it so one is so conscious of the director's force and not the playwright's words, which at times were hard to hear and comprehend, snipped into as they were by dramatic tricks, Ostermeier is a fine example of director's theatre. But if you like a well balanced production, where each nuance of a beautiful, pared script is given light and drive by actors allowed to be, rather than animated puppets, this production will probably not be for you. I came out feeling that the script potential searing beauty had been flattened by the director's own controlling vision. I highly recommend the script which can be purchased at the theatre during the run and also through bookshops from one of Britain's specialist Drama publishers, Oberon Books .
Ostermeier's directing debut at the EIF was of Marius von Mayenburg's Fireface in 1999.
Runs 12 - 17 August at 19:30, 15 & 17 August at 2:30pm
Text of this play as well as other texts of Fosse's plays are published by Oberon Books
© Thelma Good 13 August 2002
Click here to go the the fesival coverage index page Click here to go to the fringe index page Click here to go to the Book festival index page Click here to go to the EIF index page Click here to get Film festival coverage from IO Film


Edinburgh Fringe 2002
Theatre
Music
Comedy
Dance and Physical Theatre
Musicals and Opera
Children's shows
Perrier Awards
Top fringe venues
Conversations with remarkable people

Edinburgh Film Festival 2002
Reviews, daily diary, news and previews

Edinburgh International Festival 2002
International Festival reviews

Edinburgh Jazz and Blues Festival
Reviews


Bulletin boards

ARCHIVE
2003
2001
2000

 


 


Edinburgh Film
| Theatre | Edinburgh Festival

Edinburgh Accommodation :
Self-catering
| Hotels | Guesthouses | B&Bs | Serviced Apartments | Hostels


EdinburghGuide.com
1998-2007, Edinburgh, Scotland. All rights reserved.