Edinburgh Guide
Edinburgh international festival and fringe
Edinburgh : A&E : Festivals : Fringe reviews
Festival 2004
You are in the Fringe section


Musicals & Opera
A-C
D-E
F-H
I-M
N-R
S
T-Z


(T-Z) 5 out of 26 Back

Rating Guide
None = Unmissable

Full glassFull glassFull glassFull glassFull glass = Unwatchable
Page number refers to the Fringe programme



Terry Pratchett's Only You Can Save Mankind. (Page 124).
Drams full glassfull glass.
Venue Pleasance Courtyard (Venue 33).
Address 60 The Pleasance.
Reviewer Marisa de Andrade.

Only you can save mankind
Only you can save mankind
© Kevin Wilson 2004.
To save mankind in ninety minutes. Sounds like a near impossible feat. But Broadhouse Productions make a mission of it in Terry Pratchett's brave new musical Only You Can Save Mankind. From start to end it's a battle against the clock for the young actors themselves and the characters they portray. After a tentative introduction, Johnny Maxwell comes alive at the thought of the death of humanity. He wastes no time as actor, frantically delving into a science fiction story that is better served by a lengthier novel. And as character, he gains confidence in an engaging score of back-to-back musical theatre numbers.

It seems that the day a cheese-free musical will grace our stages is further in the distance than this futuristic tale of aliens and mankind becoming one in a confusing, sci-fi kind of way. Johnny Maxwell is drawn into the dimensions of a computer game bearing the title of the play. There he becomes a stronger almost alien version himself. In this dreamlike world, he finds himself belting witty lyrics quite different from the timid conversation he usually makes. It is in this fantastical place of technology, where he meets a geeky girl that helps him in his quest to save mankind. They make a stunning pair, hitting each note of the foot-tapping songs with conviction.

But their motivation for it all is a little suspect. As is the secondary plot, where a drug pushing teen faces a tragic end. It's all a bit sudden and only vaguely supplements the action, but is certainly moving. The stereotypical aliens complete with wiry headpieces seem just as haphazard as the chosen one's task. They could do with bigger budget. So could the set. Mind you, so could the festival! But, they're very entertaining and somewhat intriguing. You can't help indulge in the cosmic dreamlike fantasia before you. It's like being a part of a captivating cartoon animation that's about to come out on cable television.
© Marisa de Andrade 10 August 2004 - Published on EdinburghGuide.com
Runs 8-30 Aug, not 17 at 15.45.
Company Broadhouse Productions.

   

Treadgold Street. (Page 125).
 Drams  full glass – an enjoyable and experimental show. 
Venue  Bedlam Theatre (Venue 49).
Address 11b Bristo Place.
Reviewer Sophie Lloyd.

The Latymer Company bring to you a modern day Christmas Carol . An evening in the life of Henry Green and his trip down memory lane – or rather Treadgold Street. It is a touching theatrical production embracing film, dance and puppetry with some catchy songs thrown in.

Henry of the past and the present take it in turns to narrate. Mel Smith puts in a guest appearance on film as Henry of the present reminiscing about his past self, whom Owen Findlay simultaneously plays on stage. During the course of the play, Henry pays visits to a string of ex-girlfriends learning that as “life goes on turning”, things and people change. This whole cast ensure the audience smile, think and empathise with the characters.
 
Visuals combine well with the vocal elements in this show. The opening song, in particular, is cleverly choreographed with synchronised and mechanical movements. Additionally, puppets appear on stage - a symbolic and quirky touch, enhancing what we see as well as experimenting with movement. An otherwise simple set focuses on a door around which all the action takes place and upon which the film footage is projected. A door is symbolic of Henry’s life – his comings and goings and the ultimate passage from one stage of his life to another.

It is an original and entertaining piece of theatre performed by a talented young company.
©Sophie Lloyd 5 August 2004 - Published on EdinburghGuide.com
 Runs 9-14, 16-18, 20-21 August at 14.00.
Company – The Latymer Company.
Company Website www.treadgoldstreet.com
   

3HREE (Page 125) European premiere
Drams
None needed
Three one act musicals The Mice; Lavender Girl; Flight of the lawnchair man
Directed by Ian Davie
Performers students from The Royal Scottish Academy of Music & Drama
Venue Cowgate Central @ Cabaret Voltaire (Venue 139)
Address 36 Blair St
Reviewer Jonas Green
3HREE was commissioned by ThePrince Music Theatre, Philadelphia,Pennsylvania, which produced theWorld Premiere in October 2000.

RSAMD Musical Theatre stuents

This venue is "soaked in atmosphere" according to the Fringe Guide. Well, it's more of a grimy night-club and what has soaked it is something you might not want to dwell on. The performance space is limited and has no atmosphere in the sense of staging or scenery. But that matters not at all to this talented and enthusiastic group of a dozen RSAMD students. They make it seem like a West End stage, with a few props and costumes which are basically a job lot of dungarees and boiler suits.

They make up for these limitations with all-round vocal and dramatic skills - they can dance too but there's precious little space - in this set of three short musicals which was commissioned by the great Hal Prince from several writers. These pieces are strongly contrasted though all have some elements of black humour. The first two are oddball romances, one amusingly ironic, the other rather fey, each with a twist ending.

The first piece The Mice is the most interesting musically (the composer is one Laurence O'Keefe), while the other two depend more on stylistic parody - which is also a great stage-musical tradition.

The third, Flight of the lawnchair man is a zany tale, based on a true story, of a nerdy type who takes to the air in a garden chair lifted by 4,000 helium balloons. This piece is the most extended, long enough to have reprises and a colourful cast of characters which range from a psychotic pilot to Leonardo da Vinci.

All the individual performers are strong, and some really will make it to that West End stage. It may be invidious to mention names, but Jon Nathan as the preppy hero of Lavender Girl and later the deranged pilot has a fine voice and presence. One other limitation they have to contend with deserves a mention: the musical accompaniment is an electric piano, well-played but the most unconvincing piano sound I've heard for many years. I hope they all come back next year to a bigger venue with a decent keyboard.

© Jonas Green. 22 August 2004. Published on www.edinburghguide.co.uk See also www.rsamd.ac.uk

Run 9-30 August 2004


   

The threepenny opera (page 125)
Drams full glassfull glassfull glassfull glassfull glass
Production by MATE Drama Workshop
Cast Printed programme unavailable
Music Kurt Weill
Book and Lyrics Berthold Brecht (English translation by Marc Blitzstein)
Musicians Printed programme unavailable
Venue Sweet on the Royal Mile (Venue 39)
Address Radisson SAS Hotel, 80 High St
Reviewer Nick Scott

As this was Mate Drama Workshop's first performance of their production of Kurt Weill's The Threepenny Opera, I suspect they had more than their fair share of teething problems. But this did not excuse the lack-lustre production; and with its clumsy staging, basic sets and performances to match - these did nothing to endear Weill's marvellous score to the uninitiated; and despite Marc Blitzstein's excellent translation, much of the play's impetus was lost.

In the main, the singing hardly ever rose above the bar-room variety; and the "big-number" - Mack the Knife (which was the last song in the show) wasn't even worth the wait!

The small ensemble of musicians (with some nice clarinet playing), did well under the circumstances to keep the vocal numbers together.

Coupled with a hot and stuffy venue, it wasn't long before some members of the audience became restless, and began looking at their watches.

I'm afraid this production has few redeeming qualities; and with no printed programme - and therefore no cast list - it made it impossible to give credit for the good things.

Kurt Weill once said that there were only two kinds of music - good and bad. I presume he would have bracketed his own work in the former category - and rightly so; but after seeing this production, the unenlightened in the audience might understandably disagree.

© Nick Scott 16th August 2004

Run 15 - 17 August (16:15); 18 August (10:15); 20 - 21 August (18:15)

   

Trial by jury (Page 125)
Drams full glass full glassfull glass
Presented by Edinburgh University Savoy Opera Group
Cast Matthew Stanhope (The Judge); Karen Richmond (Angelina - The Plaintiff); Nick Clelland (Edwin - The Defendant); Lucinda Forth (Counsel for the Plaintiff); Andrew Edmonstone (Usher); Jonathan Wright (Foreman of the Jury).
Chorus: Susi Barran; Louise Christopher; Kelly Forbes; Elina Gordon; Joshua Green; Elspeth Noble; Rachel Peter; Vinca Russell; Anthony Tomlinson; Lottie Satow; Alimay Wilson
Music Arthur Sullivan
Libretto W. S. Gilbert
Musician Helen Bruce (piano)
Musical Director Gavin Easton
Co-Producers Allan Jardine and David Larking
Co-Directors Alistair Braden and Kristiana Gotzsche
Venue Bedlam Theatre (Venue 49)
Address 11b Bristo Place
Reviewer Nick Scott

I didn't go to Edinburgh University Savoy Opera Group's performance of Gilbert and Sullivan's one act opera Trial by Jury expecting to see a 'traditional' production.

Their interpretation of the plot is a novel one. The opera takes place in the country estate of a retired judge - and it is he who greets the audience as they enter the theatre. Enjoying a spot of fishing, he 'chats' to the audience - although it was directed mainly to the front two rows. At times, his ad-libbing was a little bit laboured, and I felt he wasn't entirely at ease in this role - although some of the audience seemed to enjoy it.

'Trial by Jury' has no overture; but for this production, Karen Richmond (who also played Angelina) has arranged one. It serves to 'set the scene', so to speak. That is, it accompanies a sort of 'play within a play', during which we learn of the events leading up to the trial, in which Edwin is being sued by Angelina in a breach of promise case. Step forward, the retired judge - who presides over a temporary court. Thereafter, the production adheres to the original score.

Vocally, the performance was a bit of a 'curate's egg'; and some of the ensemble items could have been tighter. Helen Bruce, at the piano, did a sterling job - although, for the larger part of the show, the tempi were on the fast side. As a result, not only much of Gilbert's clever lines and references were missed; but some of Sullivan's subtle touches were lost as well - such as the Dilemma chorus. Marked 'Andante sostenuto', the composer wanted to give the music a mock-operatic feel and 'modelled' the chorus on one from Bellini's La Sonnambula. Taken too fast - the composer's intentions are lost.

The Judge's patter song (When I good friends) was taken at breakneck speed - but here, Matthew Stanhope was more than a match for the brisk tempo. His excellent diction - apparent here and throughout the show - did 'justice' to Gilbert's witty libretto.

There are a number of 'rough edges' in this production (and, at times, has a bit of an 'end of term' school production feel about it), which, I suspect, may be the result of the 'short rehearsal period' - as mentioned in the programme. However, the production is original and full of fresh ideas, which give the story a new slant.

© Nick Scott. 24th August 2004. Published on www.edinburghguide.co.uk

Run 9 - 14 August; 23 - 28 August (22.00)

   

(T-Z) 5 out of 26 Back
Festivals homepage Edinburgh Festival Fringe Edinburgh International Festival Book Festival Film Festival Jazz & Blues Festival

Edinburgh Fringe 2004
Fringe homepage
Theatre
Music
Musicals & Opera
Dance & Physical Theatre
Comedy
Perrier Comedy Awards
Children's shows

Top fringe venues
Theatre Preview

EIF
Reviews & previews

Jazz and Blues Festival
Reviews
Preview

Edinburgh Film Festival 2004
Reviews, diary, and previews


Bulletin boards

Useful Links
Festival sites

 


 


Edinburgh Film
| Theatre | Edinburgh Festival

Edinburgh Accommodation :
Self-catering
| Hotels | Guesthouses | B&Bs | Serviced Apartments | Hostels


EdinburghGuide.com
1998-2007, Edinburgh, Scotland. All rights reserved.