City Guide to Edinburgh, Scotland

City Guide to Edinburgh, Scotland

Living Quarters Review


By Bill Dunlop - Posted on 31 October 2007

4
Show Details
Company: 
Royal Lyceum Theatre Company
Production: 
Brian Friel (writer), John Dove (director), Michael Taylor (designer), Jeannine Davies (lighting designer), Phillip Pinsky (composer / musical director), Carol Ann Crawford (voice and dialect coach)
Performers: 
Stuart McGugan (Sir), Ron Donnachie (Commandant Frank Butler), Irene Allan (Helen Butler), Niamh McCann (Miriam Donnelly), Ifan Meredith (Ben Butler), Kim Gerard (Tina Butler), Kate McGuinness (Anna Butler), Robin Laing (Charlie Donnelly), Gary Lilburn (Father Tom Carty).
Running time: 
120mins

It's always going to be interesting when the early work of an established dramatist is revived - or, in the case of 'Living Quarters' - given a belated U. K. premiere. As if, encountering an overlooked painting in a retrospective exhibition, both later themes and early influences stand out more clearly and boldly.

With Friel, we are unsurprisingly back in Ballybeg, his (necessarily) loosely imagined Donegal township and surroundings; this time not in the company of his teenaged 'Winners' or the
surveying soldiery of 'Translations', but with three sisters, their hearts
set not on Moscow (although Dublin is mentioned), but apparently intent on the
welcome of their father, lauded with hyperboles as a result of courage under
fire.

The forces surrounding Commandant Frank Butler (Ron Donnachie) at home
are considerable, while Stuart McGugan ('Sir') provides a firm hand in
propelling events to their conclusion. Although the influences on 'Living
Quarters' are paraded as clearly as the Irish tricolours decorating the
staircase of Michael Taylor's inventive set, Friel brings his considerable
powers to bear on a meditation on our ability (or inability) to re-tell our own story, elide
over what's not comfortable and somehow patch over the gaps in between. Bit like
doing history, really...

Friel's sensitivity to the past as a
perpetually unrecovered (and unrecoverable) country has made him one of the
most performed and admired of Ireland's current playwrights, speaking, it would
seem, both for and about a country in constant change which cannot completely
escape a past it fears to fully confront. The similar difficulties of other
communities make Friel both an eminently exportable commodity and spokesperson
of the perpetually regretful.

Regret washes around Commandant Butler's quarters as whiskey in the bottom of the glass of his friend Father Tom Carty (Gary Lilburn). Whether we are watching the Commandant's young second wife Anna (Katie McGuiness) squirm in guilt over her brief affair with his son, Ben (Ifan
Meredith), his daughter Helen (Irene Allan) bemoan her parent's opposition to
her doomed marriage, or Ben himself try despairingly to heal the breach
between himself and his father, regrets, stated or otherwise, strain and stain the
hero's welcome.

Perhaps unsurprisingly, the two characters
least directly involved in the events that unfold have the most resentments about their parts in it. Yet even in their selfishness, they remain the two characters truest to themselves

'Living Quarters' isn't so much 'vintage' Brian Friel as a fascinating examination of themes which have occupied dramatists from the days of Epidauros to the emergence of Twin Peaks and will always continue to do so.

Bill Dunlop, October 2007

Published on EdinburghGuide.com 2007

Tags